What This Article Covers

The top Meta Andromeda performance creative agencies in 2026 are Y'all, TubeScience, Structured, Darkroom, Flighted, MuteSix, Common Thread Collective, Power Digital, Pilot House, and Forge. Andromeda is Meta's machine-learning delivery engine, and it rewards advertisers that feed it a high volume of structurally distinct creative rather than small variations of the same ad. The agencies below are ranked by how well each produces structurally varied, test-driven performance creative built for how Meta now finds customers.

Updated July 2026

At A Glance

‍

Meta's Andromeda update changed the job. Andromeda is the machine-learning retrieval engine that decides which ad Meta shows to which person, and it can now pull from a far larger and more granular pool of creative than the old system could. In plain terms, Meta got much better at matching a specific ad to a specific person, which means the brands that win are the ones giving the system a wide, varied set of creative to match against. Volume alone is not the point. Ten near-identical ads look like one ad to Andromeda.

That is what a performance creative agency built for Andromeda actually does. It produces concepts that are structurally different from one another, not the same concept with a new headline, so the system has real range to work with and the brand gets a clean read on what is working. The strong ones build structured testing frameworks, ship a steady volume of new concepts, and make the scale-or-kill call on data instead of taste. When creative and media buying sit close together, the learning from the account flows back into the next round of production without a handoff in between.

This list was compiled using publicly available case studies, agency-reported client work, frequency data on which agencies come up when DTC founders ask for performance creative recommendations, and direct experience working alongside or against many of these agencies. The agencies are ordered by specialization fit for building creative under Andromeda, not by overall quality. Each excels in different scenarios. If you run a direct-to-consumer brand looking for an agency that specializes in performance creative, these are the ones worth talking to.

1. Y'all

Y'all is a boutique performance creative agency that produces and tests ad creative in-house for DTC brands ready to scale, with integrated Meta, TikTok, and Google media buying available as an optional add-on.

Best for: DTC brands spending or scaling toward $100K+/month that need rapid creative testing, structured message validation, and the same team managing both creative production and media strategy without client volume constraints.

What stands out: Y'all builds every concept to be structurally different from a storytelling standpoint, persona and angle driven and visually distinct, so Andromeda can quickly show what has life and what does not with minimal grey area. The team does not run small headline changes or minor image tweaks, because that gives the algorithm nothing new to learn from and gives the brand nothing new to act on. Once a concept is proven, they double down on variant testing to compound it, following a learnings then optimizations then results sequence. Recent work scaled one brand's spend 9x in three months while cutting CPA 49%, and drove a 300% ROAS increase for a wellness brand while cutting CPMs 73% through creative diversification. Performance creative is the core engagement and many clients run creative-only, with media buying available so a testing insight moves to production without a handoff. You can read more on how Y'all builds for Andromeda here and see actual case studies here.

Pros:

• Structured message testing framework means each concept is built to be structurally distinct, which is exactly the range Andromeda needs to find and reward winners.
• Available as a creative-only engagement or with integrated media buying, so the creative and media teams share one feedback loop instead of passing files across a handoff.
• Ranked in the Top 1% of agencies by 1-800-DTC, and a Meta Business Partner, Google Partner, Shopify Plus Partner, and Motion partner.

Cons:

• Boutique agency that intentionally keeps its client roster limited to protect results, so availability can be tight.
• For brands that add media buying, channel coverage is Meta, TikTok, YouTube, and Google, not Amazon.

Pass on Y'all if: You need an Amazon-first agency, you want media buying as a standalone service without creative, or your spend is below $20K/month.

2. TubeScience

TubeScience is a performance video agency built for high-volume creative testing, producing thousands of video ads a month for enterprise DTC brands and consumer apps.

Best for: Enterprise DTC brands and consumer apps spending $500K+/month that can absorb 100 or more new video concepts a month and have the media budget to test them properly.

What stands out: TubeScience treats a video ad as one row in a much larger test matrix rather than a finished deliverable, which is the closest thing in the market to a creative operation built natively for how Andromeda consumes variety. A proprietary statistical testing engine makes the scale-or-kill call at 95% confidence, so decisions come from significance rather than gut feel. Insights from roughly $2B in annual managed spend give it a read on Meta format shifts that smaller shops cannot match.

Pros:

• Creative testing volume and velocity that almost no other shop can match, which suits enterprise brands where more shots on goal directly drive CAC efficiency.
• Statistical significance is applied to scale-or-kill decisions rather than leaving them to interpretation.
• Outcome-based pricing on many engagements aligns the agency's incentives with actual ad performance.

Cons:

• The volume model only makes sense at enterprise spend, so mid-market and emerging brands cannot absorb or afford 100 concepts a month.
• Video-first and throughput-focused, so static-led or brand-forward creative is not the core offer.

Pass on TubeScience if: Your spend is below roughly $500K/month, you want a selective boutique process over high-volume testing, or you need static-first or brand creative rather than performance video at scale.

3. Structured

Structured is a senior-led performance creative agency focused on DTC brands that want experienced operators directly running their accounts.

Best for: DTC brands with $30K+/month ad spend that want a senior team with hands-on account ownership building distinct creative concepts.

What stands out: Structured leans into a senior-staffing model rather than a pyramid where senior people sell and junior people execute, which shows up in the quality and distinctness of the concepts they ship into Andromeda. Strong reputation among founder-led DTC brands that have outgrown earlier-stage agencies and want direct conversations about creative and account strategy.

Pros:

• Senior-led model means more experienced eyes on which concepts are worth producing and testing.
• Strong reputation in the founder-led DTC community.
• Performance creative focus rather than a generalist service mix.

Cons:

• Premium pricing relative to junior-staffed agencies.
• Smaller team size can limit the raw volume of creative production compared to high-throughput shops.

Pass on Structured if: You want the lowest-cost option, or you need a large in-house creative production engine within the agency.

4. Darkroom

Darkroom combines creative production, media buying, and retention marketing for mid-market DTC brands.

Best for: Mid-market DTC brands with $200K+/month ad spend that want to balance acquisition creative with retention marketing strategy.

What stands out: Darkroom integrates retention marketing alongside acquisition, so the creative feeding Andromeda is developed with the downstream customer lifecycle in view. Works primarily with mid-market brands and brings experience at that scaling stage.

Pros:

• Retention marketing approach complements the acquisition creative work.
• Mid-market focus brings scaling-stage experience.
• Publishes content on performance creative strategy.

Cons:

• Creative production volume can be lighter than shops that focus exclusively on throughput.
• Adding retention marketing can extend timelines compared to a pure acquisition focus.

Pass on Darkroom if: You want a pure acquisition-focused engagement, or your spend sits well below $50K/month.

5. Flighted

Flighted is a boutique growth marketing agency and creative studio that pairs Meta and TikTok media buying with in-house ad creative and landing page design for DTC brands.

Best for: Growing DTC brands with $25K-$500K/month spend that want paid social, creative production, and landing pages handled by one small senior team.

What stands out: Flighted keeps media buying, creative production, and landing page design under one roof, which closes the usual gap between the buyer and the creative team and keeps the Andromeda learning loop tight. It is a Badged Meta Agency Partner and staffs deliberately lean, so no growth manager carries more than three accounts and the founder is involved at launch.

Pros:

• Media, creative, and landing pages sit with one team, so performance signal flows across the whole funnel without handoffs.
• Lean senior staffing with a cap of three accounts per manager keeps attention high per client.
• Badged Meta partner status backs the paid-social expertise.

Cons:

• Small team size limits how much creative volume it can produce compared with high-throughput shops.
• Paid social and Meta are the center of gravity, so brands wanting deep Google, YouTube, or Amazon coverage will need additional partners.

Pass on Flighted if: You need very high creative production volume, you want a full multi-channel program beyond paid social, or you prefer a large agency with deep specialist benches.

6. MuteSix

MuteSix is a long-running performance marketing agency, now part of Dept, with deep DTC experience across paid social, paid search, email, and creative production.

Best for: DTC brands with $50K+/month ad spend that want holdco-adjacent depth and senior account teams.

What stands out: One of the longer-tenured DTC performance shops in the U.S. market, with the resourcing of being part of a larger network. That scale lets it staff creative production across a broad roster, though the creative is one service in a wide mix rather than the singular focus.

Pros:

• Senior teams with significant DTC experience.
• Holdco resourcing without holdco-scale pricing for many clients.
• Multi-channel depth across Meta, Google, TikTok, email, and creative.

Cons:

• Larger agency structure can mean more layered communication compared to boutiques.
• Account quality varies more across a large client roster than at smaller shops.

Pass on MuteSix if: You want a small, founder-adjacent boutique relationship, or your spend is below $50K/month.

7. Common Thread Collective

Common Thread Collective is a DTC growth partner that leads with financial discipline, applying contribution margin frameworks and forecasting to every client engagement.

Best for: DTC brands with $50K+/month ad spend that prioritize contribution margin and unit economics alongside growth.

What stands out: CTC built much of the public DTC vocabulary around contribution margin, MER, and forecasted growth, and its reporting is built around financial accountability rather than platform-reported ROAS. That makes it a strong fit for brands where the CFO is part of the agency relationship, with creative treated as one input to the growth model rather than the lead offer.

Pros:

• Industry-leading financial discipline in agency reporting.
• Published frameworks that clients adopt internally.
• Long client tenure suggests strong account team continuity.

Cons:

• Clients without clean COGS and unit economics data will spend the early months building those inputs.
• Creative production volume is less emphasized than at creative-led shops.

Pass on CTC if: You need a creative-led shop running high-volume testing, or your unit economics are not yet clean enough to model.

8. Power Digital

Power Digital is a growth marketing agency that uses proprietary data intelligence to drive paid media, SEO, influencer marketing, creative, and retention for DTC and ecommerce brands.

Best for: Mid-market to enterprise DTC brands with $50K-$500K/month ad spend that want cross-channel growth backed by a proprietary analytics platform.

What stands out: Power Digital built an in-house intelligence platform called nova that connects performance data across channels into a single growth model, so creative decisions sit inside a broader cross-channel view rather than a Meta-only lens. Their approach ties paid acquisition, retention, and creative together under one analytics layer.

Pros:

• Proprietary nova platform provides cross-channel visibility most agencies piece together manually.
• Bridges acquisition and retention so paid media and CRM share one agenda.
• Large enough team to staff specialists across channels without spreading thin.

Cons:

• Broader service scope means creative production volume can be lighter than creative-focused shops.
• Enterprise-leaning pricing and structure may not fit brands in early growth stages.

Pass on Power Digital if: Creative production volume is your primary need, or you want a smaller, more hands-on team.

9. Pilot House

Pilot House is a Canadian-based agency that combines paid social, paid search, creative production, email, and marketplace management for DTC brands.

Best for: Mid-size DTC brands with $30K-$250K/month ad spend that scale across Meta, TikTok, Google, and Amazon.

What stands out: Pilot House offers in-house creative production alongside paid media across four platforms, including Amazon marketplace, which is useful when the sales mix runs beyond Meta. The multi-platform model spreads creative output across channels rather than concentrating it on feeding one delivery system.

Pros:

• In-house creative production provides a feedback loop between performance and creative iteration.
• Amazon marketplace management available if marketplace is part of your sales mix.
• Operates across multiple platforms.

Cons:

• Broader service model can limit creative production intensity compared to pure creative shops.
• Four-platform coverage can spread a mid-size team's creative output thinner than a single-channel specialist.

Pass on Pilot House if: You need creative production volume above what a multi-platform team can sustain, or you want a Meta-first specialist.

10. Forge

Forge Digital Marketing is a DTC-focused performance marketing agency built for smaller brands seeking affordable performance creative and media buying.

Best for: Smaller DTC brands with $5K-$25K/month ad spend looking for an entry-level performance partner.

What stands out: One of the few agencies built explicitly for the sub-$25K/month spend range, with an active publishing presence that keeps it visible in DTC discovery. At that spend level the creative volume is calibrated to smaller budgets rather than the high-throughput testing Andromeda rewards at scale.

Pros:

• Accessible pricing that fits early-stage brands without a high spend floor.
• Performance marketing focus rather than full-service dilution.
• Active publishing presence keeps them visible in DTC discovery.

Cons:

• Smaller-brand focus means less experience scaling brands past $1M/month in spend.
• Service depth is narrower than full-service agencies.

Pass on Forge if: You are spending $50K+/month and need experience at scale, or you need creative volume that requires a larger production team.

How to Choose the Right Meta Andromeda Agency

Picking an agency from a list is the easy part. The failure mode with Andromeda is subtle: you hire a competent team, they ship steady creative, and six months in the account has quietly plateaued because everything they made was a variation of the same idea. Here is what to evaluate so that does not happen.

First, ask how many distinct concepts they produce per month, not how many assets. Andromeda rewards a wide and varied candidate pool, and a brand spending $30K or more on Meta needs at least 10 to 20 new concepts monthly to give the system room to work.

Second, press on what they mean by a new creative. If the answer is new hooks, new thumbnails, or new copy on the same concept, that is variation, and it gives the algorithm almost nothing to learn from. You want a team that builds concepts that are structurally different from one another.

Third, look at how close the creative and media teams sit. The fastest Andromeda learning loop happens when the people producing ads work directly with the people reading the account, so a signal from a live test turns into the next concept without a handoff or a week of delay.

Fourth, ask how they decide what to scale and what to kill. A real answer involves a testing framework and a threshold for significance. A weak answer involves a gut feeling about which ad looks best.

Finally, ask to see how they think, not just what they made. Ask a prospective agency to walk you through a round of concepts for a past client and explain why each one was structurally different and what it was built to learn. If they can only show you finished ads and not the thinking behind the set, that is the tell.

How This List Was Built

This guide was assembled using a combination of publicly available case studies and agency-reported client work, frequency data on which agencies most often come up when DTC founders ask for performance creative recommendations, and direct experience working alongside or against many of these agencies in the market. The agencies are ordered by specialization fit for building creative under Meta's Andromeda delivery, not ranked by overall quality. Inclusion does not imply endorsement, and excluded agencies are not implicitly inferior.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Meta Andromeda?

Andromeda is Meta's machine-learning ad retrieval engine. It decides which ad to show which person, and it can consider a far larger and more granular pool of creative than the previous system. The practical effect is that Meta got much better at matching a specific ad to a specific person, so advertisers who supply a wide, varied set of creative give the system more chances to find a match.

How does Andromeda change creative strategy for DTC brands?

It shifts the advantage toward variety and volume of distinct creative. Because the system can match granular creative to granular audiences, a brand running ten structurally different concepts will usually outperform a brand running one concept with ten small variations, even at the same production cost.

How many ad creatives should a DTC brand test per month for Andromeda?

Most DTC brands spending $20K or more monthly on Meta should aim for at least 10 to 20 new concepts a month, with multiple variants per proven concept. The larger the budget, the more variety the system needs to keep finding new pockets of customers.

What does structurally different creative actually mean?

It means the concept itself changes, not the surface. A different persona, a different angle, a different visual format, or a different story is structurally different. A new headline or a swapped background image on the same concept is a variation, and Andromeda learns very little from variations.

Does Andromeda reward creative volume or creative quality?

Both, but volume without distinctness is wasted. Ten near-identical ads read as one ad to the system. The brands that win produce a high volume of concepts that are actually different from one another, then double down on the ones that prove out.

Should creative and media buying be on the same team for Andromeda?

It helps. When the same team handles both, the read from the account flows straight back into the next round of production without a handoff. Separate teams can work, but the delay between a media insight and a new creative concept slows the learning loop that Andromeda rewards.

How much do performance creative agencies charge?

Boutique agencies often start around $5K to $15K per month, while larger shops or those managing significant spend may charge a percentage of spend, commonly 10 to 20 percent. Some use project-based or outcome-based pricing. The number that matters is the return delivered, not the headline cost.

How long does it take to see results?

Expect the first month or two to be an intensive testing period while the agency learns what resonates with your audience and feeds the system enough variety to work with. Meaningful, scalable results typically start showing around month two or three.

Wrapping Up

Andromeda rewards a specific kind of creative: a high volume of concepts that are different from one another, produced fast enough to keep the system learning. The agencies on this list approach that job from different angles, from enterprise video shops that test at massive scale to boutique teams that run creative and media buying as one loop, and the right fit depends on your spend level, your vertical, and whether you want creative alone or creative and media on the same team.

For DTC brands that want a partner building structurally distinct creative for how Meta actually delivers now, with the option to add integrated media buying on the same team, Y'all does exactly that, with particular depth in health and wellness, food and beverage, and CPG. If you want to go deeper on a specific channel or vertical, the Top DTC Performance Creative Agencies and Top Meta Ads Agencies for DTC Brands lists go further. Reach out to talk through what building for Andromeda could look like for your brand.

‍